Delia Smith Butterscotch Sauce

Delia Smith butterscotch sauce, smooth and glossy, poured from a jug over two scoops of vanilla ice cream, with the saucepan and a jar of sauce behind

Real Delia Smith butterscotch sauce is butter, soft brown and white sugar and syrup melted together, then made thick and smooth with double cream. You need one pan and about 20 minutes, and the recipe makes enough for 6 people. Pour it over vanilla ice cream on its own, or add chopped bananas or sliced fresh peaches.

Page 409 of her Complete Cookery Course (1992) has the recipe, and the 1983 edition gives exactly the same amounts on page 448. She says people “never fail to drool over” this thick sauce.

The same butterscotch goes inside her banana and butterscotch trifle, made there with a little more cream, 150ml. For the sticky pudding with dates, her toffee sauce is a different recipe, with pecans, and it bubbles under the grill.

Delia Butterscotch Sauce

Recipe by Hamdi Saidani
0.0 from 0 votes

Her thick butterscotch sauce of butter, soft brown and granulated sugar and syrup, finished with double cream and vanilla.

Course: SauceCuisine: BritishDifficulty: Easy
Servings

6

servings
Prep time

5

minutes
Cooking time

15

minutes
Calories

300

kcal

Ingredients

  • For the sauce:
  • 50g butter

  • 75g soft brown sugar

  • 50g granulated sugar

  • 150g golden syrup (about a third of a 450g tin)

  • 110ml double cream

  • a few drops of vanilla essence

Directions

  • Melt: Put the butter, both sugars and the syrup in a medium, thick-based saucepan. Heat it slowly until everything has melted and the sugar has dissolved into a liquid.
  • Cook: Leave it over a gentle heat for about 5 minutes more, then turn the heat off.
  • Cream: Stir in the double cream a little at a time, followed by a few drops of vanilla essence.
  • Smooth: Keep stirring for 2 to 3 minutes, until the sauce is absolutely smooth.
  • Serve: Serve it straight away while hot, or let it cool.

Notes

  • Leftover sauce keeps well for several weeks in a screw-top jar in a cool place.

FAQs

Which sugar can I use?

Light muscovado works too, as her website makes the same sauce with it instead of the soft brown sugar. It also swaps the white for unrefined granulated. The method stays exactly the same, and that version from her 2003 Christmas magazine cools before it goes over bananas and ice cream.

In How to Cook Book Two (1999, page 21), she explains what unrefined sugars are. They are made from pure sugar cane, and the colour and flavour of the cane are not refined out of them. On the same page, she also calls the syrup a very British favourite for sauces, puddings and butterscotch, or spread thickly on homemade bread.

How do I make it darker?

Add a little molasses, a trick from her 1999 book. Dark syrup was still in the shops when she first started cooking, but a little molasses added to the syrup now gives the same effect. Start with about a teaspoon in this sauce, which is our own amount, then taste.

Molasses is the dark syrup left over once sugar has been refined, and it is very concentrated, so only a little is needed. She also uses it instead of black treacle in recipes, because the flavour is much richer, even though it costs more.

How do I make a small amount for one?

Her One Is Fun (1985; page 204 of the 1987 paperback) scales it down for a single bowl. She describes it as a sticky sauce made for bananas, at its best served hot.

It uses 10g of butter, 25g of soft brown sugar and a tablespoon each of syrup and cream. There is no white sugar or vanilla in this small version.

The butter, sugar and syrup melt very slowly over the lowest heat, which can take 10 to 15 minutes. The cream goes in with the heat off, then the hot sauce is poured over sliced banana and vanilla ice cream. A few chopped nuts on top are her own extra.

Why has my sauce gone grainy?

Graininess comes from sugar crystals that had not dissolved before the pan was left to cook. The small One Is Fun version guards against it, because you stir and check that every grain has gone before the cream goes in.

If it has already turned grainy, add a tablespoon of water and warm it gently, stirring, until the crystals melt again. That fix is our own tip.

Can I make a caramel sauce instead?

Yes, her One Is Fun (page 203) has a caramel sauce for one person, made quite differently from this butterscotch. It uses no butter or syrup, only light soft brown sugar melted on its own, then hot water and single cream. She spoons it over a poached pear.

Recommended Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *